Trying to decide between Payroll Mate and OnPay? Both are industry-leading solutions, but which one is the best fit for your business? In this detailed comparison, we evaluate their features, pricing, ease of use, and customer support to help you make an informed choice. Whether you need advanced automation, better scalability, or user-friendly interfaces, this guide breaks down everything you need to know to select the right software for your needs.
Explore other software products that may fit your needs before making a final choice.
Sponsored
Compare ratings, pricing, descriptions, buyer fit, integrations, category features, product details, alternatives, and SoftwareWorld’s final conclusion with Payroll Mate on the left and OnPay on the right.
Payroll Mate
Visit Website
OnPay
Visit Website
See ratings, free-trial availability, starting price, and a short description for each product in two dedicated columns.
Software
Payroll Mate is a comprehensive payroll software that simplifies payroll management for small and medium-sized businesses. The software automates the calculation of wages, taxes, and deductions, ensuring accuracy in every...
Read more about Payroll Mate
Software
OnPay is a comprehensive, cloud-based payroll software, tailored for small to medium-sized businesses. It stands out for its simplicity and affordability, making payroll processing effortless even for those without prior...
Read more about OnPayOpen any shared category to compare the features selected under that category for both products.
Features shown here belong only to the Compliance Software category.
| Feature | Payroll Mate | OnPay |
|---|---|---|
| HIPAA Compliant | Listed | Listed |
| Compliance Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| Risk Assessment | Listed | Listed |
| Environmental Compliance | Listed | Listed |
| Policy Management | Listed | Listed |
| Alerts/Escalation | Listed | Listed |
| ISO Compliance | Listed | Listed |
| Incident Management | Listed | Listed |
| Risk Management | Listed | Listed |
| OSHA Compliance | Listed | Listed |
| Document Management | Listed | Listed |
| Task Management | Listed | Listed |
| Surveys & Feedback | Listed | Listed |
| Training Management | Listed | Listed |
| Compliance Management | Listed | Listed |
| FDA Compliance | Listed | Listed |
| Audit Management | Listed | Listed |
| Audit Trail | Listed | Listed |
| Controls Audit | Listed | Listed |
| Access Controls/Permissions | Listed | Listed |
| Artificial Intelligence | Not listed | Not listed |
Features shown here belong only to the Human Resources Software category.
| Feature | Payroll Mate | OnPay |
|---|---|---|
| Performance Management | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Database | Listed | Listed |
| Applicant Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| Compensation Management | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Management | Listed | Listed |
| Recruitment Management | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Profiles | Listed | Listed |
| Succession Planning | Listed | Listed |
| Benefits Management | Listed | Listed |
| Time & Attendance | Listed | Listed |
| Learning & Development | Listed | Listed |
| Self Service Portal | Listed | Listed |
| Reporting/Analytics | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Onboarding | Listed | Listed |
| Training Management | Listed | Listed |
| Payroll Management | Listed | Listed |
| Sick Leave Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| HR Management | Listed | Listed |
| Calendar Management | Listed | Listed |
| Approval Process Control | Listed | Listed |
| Vacation/Leave Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| Document Management | Listed | Listed |
| 360 Degree Feedback | Listed | Listed |
| Time Off Management | Listed | Listed |
| Compliance Management | Listed | Listed |
| Access Controls/Permissions | Listed | Listed |
| Attendance Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| Artificial Intelligence | Not listed | Not listed |
Features shown here belong only to the Payroll Software category.
| Feature | Payroll Mate | OnPay |
|---|---|---|
| Check Printing | Listed | Listed |
| Direct Deposit | Listed | Listed |
| Compensation Management | Listed | Listed |
| Tax Compliance | Listed | Listed |
| Multi-State | Listed | Listed |
| Compliance Management | Listed | Listed |
| Alerts/Notifications | Listed | Listed |
| Approval Process Control | Listed | Listed |
| Time Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| Benefits Management | Listed | Listed |
| Payroll Outsourcing | Listed | Listed |
| Payroll Reporting | Listed | Listed |
| Document Management | Listed | Listed |
| Payroll Management | Listed | Listed |
| Vacation/Leave Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| Activity Dashboard | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Profiles | Listed | Listed |
| Calendar Management | Listed | Listed |
| Multi-Country | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Database | Listed | Listed |
| Access Controls/Permissions | Listed | Listed |
| Self Service Portal | Listed | Listed |
| Reporting & Statistics | Listed | Listed |
| Artificial Intelligence | Not listed | Not listed |
Features shown here belong only to the Direct Deposit Payroll Software category.
| Feature | Payroll Mate | OnPay |
|---|---|---|
| Approval Process Control | Listed | Listed |
| Dashboard | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Database | Listed | Listed |
| Payroll Management | Listed | Listed |
| Payroll Reporting | Listed | Listed |
| Tax Compliance | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Self Service | Listed | Listed |
| Time Tracking | Listed | Listed |
| W-2 Preparation | Listed | Listed |
| Benefits Management | Listed | Listed |
| Compensation Management | Listed | Listed |
| Employee Profiles | Listed | Listed |
| Artificial Intelligence | Not listed | Not listed |
Compare deployment, device support, pricing model, support channels, and target company size for both products.
Explore alternatives to Payroll Mate and OnPay before making a final choice.
Explore other software products that buyers may consider instead of Payroll Mate.
Explore other software products that buyers may consider instead of OnPay.
This comparison brings public profile information, category-specific feature selections, review visibility, and clearly labeled sponsored placements together in a structured format so you can evaluate both products with confidence.
Each section keeps Payroll Mate and OnPay in clearly separated columns so you can compare equivalent information without losing context.
Shared categories open into their own feature comparisons, helping you review use-case-specific capabilities rather than only broad product claims.
Sponsored products stay outside the detailed comparison, and paid placements are clearly labeled so the core comparison remains focused on Payroll Mate and OnPay.
Profile pages, category pages, integrations, and alternatives are linked throughout the page so you can continue your research from the same comparison.
